PDA

View Full Version : One Old Song, Any Old Song, on the next album


MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 01:27 PM
What pick you? Anything from Mother's Night to The Song That Jane Likes to True Reflections to Get In Line to Dream I Killed God to Crazy Easy to Sweet Up and Down to Monkey Man to Loving Wings to Sugar Will to #36 to Spotlight.

One song on the next album.

kgs305
03-22-2008, 01:31 PM
Studio #40.

Mateo2k
03-22-2008, 01:32 PM
Can't Stop.

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 01:32 PM
Can't Stop.

but seriously.

spoot388
03-22-2008, 01:34 PM
The only old songs I would support are songs that never really got a chance in the first place, like Dream I Killed God. They could make a hell of a song out of that, but they probably never will. But it would be "new" because for all these years now, its never been played full band, so we have no idea what to expect from it.

I just don't want the new album to be littered with old stuff. Its a NEW album. I don't want any of the 04 songs on there (way overrated), no LWS leftovers, unless its the new SUAD, and I'd rather not waste a spot on a song like Loving Wings (and Granny, STJL, ect) because they already play it even without being on an album, save the spot for something new.

bibby1044
03-22-2008, 01:35 PM
LWS Captain, but that cant happen...so I have no idea.

thestand
03-22-2008, 01:36 PM
I'd love for a LWS song to get done, just so there's a better chance of them getting toured. But I'd much rather get a song that we don't have a studio version of. So, in all, probably Sugar Will. Unless they plan on doing a vault release in the future, which the Trey Sugar Will would ome out of.

DerekJTR2
03-22-2008, 01:46 PM
What pick you? Anything from Mother's Night to The Song That Jane Likes to True Reflections to Get In Line to Dream I Killed God to Crazy Easy to Sweet Up and Down to Monkey Man to Loving Wings to Sugar Will to #36 to Spotlight.

One song on the next album.

Not Song that Jane Likes or True Reflections, come on

I think Blue Water would be incredible. With Dave's more adult voice (less munchkiny) it could be great. Only question is why doesn't he play it anymore?

dreamingtree_34
03-22-2008, 01:46 PM
dreamed i killed god would be absolutely amazing. it would definitely help give the album a dark feel. so would deed is done. throw in blue water, a perfectly lyriced shotgun, some segues and a few good new tunes and the albums guaranteed to be great. its sucks that these are all ridiculously unlikely if not impossible

Swizz2007
03-22-2008, 01:47 PM
I'd love for a LWS song to get done, just so there's a better chance of them getting toured. But I'd much rather get a song that we don't have a studio version of. So, in all, probably Sugar Will. Unless they plan on doing a vault release in the future, which the Trey Sugar Will would ome out of.

I really think they should do that

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 02:09 PM
Not Song that Jane Likes or True Reflections, come on

I think Blue Water would be incredible. With Dave's more adult voice (less munchkiny) it could be great. Only question is why doesn't he play it anymore?

I don't want this touched until

a) Cavallo shows that he is capable and

b) the band shows that it is serious about making great studio records again.

I don't need a butchered Blue Water...

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 02:09 PM
I'd love for a LWS song to get done, just so there's a better chance of them getting toured. But I'd much rather get a song that we don't have a studio version of. So, in all, probably Sugar Will. Unless they plan on doing a vault release in the future, which the Trey Sugar Will would ome out of.

Thi$ will definitely happen at $ome point.

GoodDayIIDie
03-22-2008, 02:15 PM
Kind Intentions.

dmb5570
03-22-2008, 02:28 PM
i would be really excited for a studio dreamed i killed god or #40 based on yoshis lyrics.

dmbmuskie
03-22-2008, 02:29 PM
A few old songs would provide a benchmark for the rest of the release. I'm all for them recording Seek Up because I think it's the best song they still play not officialy released.

spoot388
03-22-2008, 02:46 PM
A few old songs would provide a benchmark for the rest of the release. I'm all for them recording Seek Up because I think it's the best song they still play not officialy released.



But whats the point of having it on a new album? They already play it, everyone knows it. Guarantee that after the first time you hear it, you'll think "nice, a studio Seek Up." and then after that you'll realize "why did they waste a spot on an album for this when it could have been a new song?"

Sure it would be cool to hear, but there really is no point of having a studio version of a song that was already played like 600 times.

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 02:52 PM
But whats the point of having it on a new album? They already play it, everyone knows it. Guarantee that after the first time you hear it, you'll think "nice, a studio Seek Up." and then after that you'll realize "why did they waste a spot on an album for this when it could have been a new song?"

Sure it would be cool to hear, but there really is no point of having a studio version of a song that was already played like 600 times.

They haven't utilized their "new song" slots very well though, have they?

dmbfan4ever
03-22-2008, 03:04 PM
For me it has to be Monkey Man. This song is just too perfect...lyrically, musically, orgasmically.....

spoot388
03-22-2008, 03:04 PM
They haven't utilized their "new song" slots very well though, have they?



If we were going to get another Stand Up, sure, then throw in a studio Seek Up and whatever other old song that hasn't been released yet. But there is actually some potential for a good, if not great album this time. Tim being in the studio with them should alone be enough to give this album a chance at being good. But they already have some promising stuff already made. This album could be really good.

dmbmuskie
03-22-2008, 03:06 PM
But whats the point of having it on a new album? They already play it, everyone knows it. Guarantee that after the first time you hear it, you'll think "nice, a studio Seek Up." and then after that you'll realize "why did they waste a spot on an album for this when it could have been a new song?"

Sure it would be cool to hear, but there really is no point of having a studio version of a song that was already played like 600 times.

It provides a benchmark for the rest of the music they would be creating.

Smooth Rider is bad, but it's epically bad when it's placed in between two songs from the beginning to 2000.

dmbmuskie
03-22-2008, 03:10 PM
If we were going to get another Stand Up, sure, then throw in a studio Seek Up and whatever other old song that hasn't been released yet. But there is actually some potential for a good, if not great album this time. Tim being in the studio with them should alone be enough to give this album a chance at being good. But they already have some promising stuff already made. This album could be really good.

That is where we disagree. I don't think they have done anything worthwhile since 2004, with the original Shotgun being the exception.

I'd rather have another Busted Stuff, full of unuinspired recordings of songs we have all heard before, than another Stand Up.

My hope would be for 10-12 amazing new songs, but I just don't believe they can do it. 5-7 is much more realistic.

spoot388
03-22-2008, 03:15 PM
It provides a benchmark for the rest of the music they would be creating.

Smooth Rider is bad, but it's epically bad when it's placed in between two songs from the beginning to 2000.



No it doesn't. Its music they made 15+ years ago that they are just polishing up. There is no new creative song writing being done. They don't even have to think when they play Seek Up because they've done it so much already. It would just be going through the motions for the sake of making a studio version. It will prove NOTHING in the way of if they can still write music that good.

The band taking something like a Two Step Intro and building a song around that that is as good as Seek Up will be a benchmark for the rest of the album, not remaking Seek Up.

bphlzl
03-22-2008, 03:21 PM
The only old songs I would support are songs that never really got a chance in the first place, like Dream I Killed God. They could make a hell of a song out of that, but they probably never will. But it would be "new" because for all these years now, its never been played full band, so we have no idea what to expect from it.

I just don't want the new album to be littered with old stuff. Its a NEW album. I don't want any of the 04 songs on there (way overrated), no LWS leftovers, unless its the new SUAD, and I'd rather not waste a spot on a song like Loving Wings (and Granny, STJL, ect) because they already play it even without being on an album, save the spot for something new.
I disagree with every single thing you said... except for the part about DIKG, because that would be awesome!

My choice: Sugar Will.

thestand
03-22-2008, 03:38 PM
Thi$ will definitely happen at $ome point.$o will a new album. $o I'm not really $ure why thi$ is ne$$e$$ary. I just don't see the point in saying it's just for money. I mean, if we do it, it'll probably be one of the best things they've ever done. I mean, just think of what they have that we don't have. They have a few versions of Granny, a few versions of #40, a few versions of Kind Intentions, a few versions of Get in Line, a few #36, Deed is Done, Don't Burn the Pig, Little Thing, MacHead, Sugar Will, Crazy Easy, JTR (mixed & mastered), Monkey Man (m&m), BYAH (m&M), SUAD (m&M). And those are only the things we know about. It would be a service to the fans, and one of, if not THE coolest things they've ever done.

For me it has to be Monkey Man. This song is just too perfect...lyrically, musically, orgasmically.....7 years later, and this song still bores me to tears.

dreamstree41
03-22-2008, 03:41 PM
Monkey Man. Please.

spoot388
03-22-2008, 03:45 PM
I disagree with every single thing you said... except for the part about DIKG, because that would be awesome!

My choice: Sugar Will.


I'm sorry you have an ass backwards belief of the purpose of new albums.




$o will a new album. $o I'm not really $ure why thi$ is ne$$e$$ary. I just don't see the point in saying it's just for money. I mean, if we do it, it'll probably be one of the best things they've ever done. I mean, just think of what they have that we don't have. They have a few versions of Granny, a few versions of #40, a few versions of Kind Intentions, a few versions of Get in Line, a few #36, Deed is Done, Don't Burn the Pig, Little Thing, MacHead, Sugar Will, Crazy Easy, JTR (mixed & mastered), Monkey Man (m&m), BYAH (m&M), SUAD (m&M). And those are only the things we know about. It would be a service to the fans, and one of, if not THE coolest things they've ever done.

7 years later, and this song still bores me to tears.


You know what'll happen, we'll get all these unreleased songs (the ones we don't know about) and think "holy damn they suck". it would definitely be cool to have, but i have a feeling we wouldn't voluntarily listen to half the stuff because we would realize why it was left off the albums in the first place.


as for Monkey Man, I agree. its pretty boring.

bphlzl
03-22-2008, 03:49 PM
I'm sorry you have an ass backwards belief of the purpose of new albums.No, not really. I like albums to not only be full of good songs, but to be fit together into one unit that I will want to listen to over and over again. I don't care about the "new" aspect, meaning songs that haven't been worked on before.

dre2142
03-22-2008, 03:49 PM
I'm sorry you have an ass backwards belief of the purpose of new albums.









And what IS the purpose? How would this album be much different from the past albums....songs that they tested out on tour. I want a good mix of unreleased old and new.

chr35919
03-22-2008, 04:15 PM
recently.

superfan
03-22-2008, 07:23 PM
Good Good Time or Crazy Easy

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 07:49 PM
The purpose of releasing studio albums, to me, is to release great studio albums.

The band is 3/6 at this.

If the purpose of new studio albums was were to introduce a whole bunch of great new songs live, then the band would be 1/6, the one being BTCS. Most of Crash had already been played quite a bit before recording, and all of UTTAD was.

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 07:50 PM
^From me as a fan's perspective, of course. Obviously, the real purpose is to make a profit, but that isn't what this conversation is about.

ZackR
03-22-2008, 08:04 PM
The purpose of releasing studio albums, to me, is to release great studio albums.

The band is 3/6 at this.

If the purpose of new studio albums was were to introduce a whole bunch of great new songs live, then the band would be 1/6, the one being BTCS. Most of Crash had already been played quite a bit before recording, and all of UTTAD was.Exactly right.

coldengrey12
03-22-2008, 08:19 PM
The purpose of releasing studio albums, to me, is to release great studio albums.

The band is 3/6 at this.

If the purpose of new studio albums was were to introduce a whole bunch of great new songs live, then the band would be 1/6, the one being BTCS. Most of Crash had already been played quite a bit before recording, and all of UTTAD was.

Not to be a dick, but wouldn't that make them one out of four then? I guess I just don't like the way 1/6 looks. *chuckles*

Oh, and my answer to your original question is JTR.

pdoseven
03-22-2008, 08:31 PM
I really love build you a house

Swizz2007
03-22-2008, 08:50 PM
I'd choose Crazy Easy because I don't think it'd be too hard to nail. Whereas, while I think Sugar Will has more potential, I could pretty easily see them fucking that one up.

Pig17
03-22-2008, 08:51 PM
Monkey Man

jpgreen
03-22-2008, 08:51 PM
Light Lift Me Up

Pig17
03-22-2008, 08:51 PM
I really love build you a house

I would love to see it too, but it has already been used in EWU (which I only just found out).

pdoseven
03-22-2008, 09:10 PM
I would love to see it too, but it has already been used in EWU (which I only just found out).
WHHHAAATTT?!?!?

but EWU sucks

ahh life's a bitch
:D

TwoStep2888
03-22-2008, 09:18 PM
Hold Me Down

Gladstone
03-22-2008, 09:22 PM
Kind Intentions.

:thumbsup

Kind Intentions, but based on the soundcheck, not on the demo.

#2 would be Blue Water

#3 would be #40

thestand
03-22-2008, 09:31 PM
The purpose of releasing studio albums, to me, is to release great studio albums.

The band is 3/6 at this.

If the purpose of new studio albums was were to introduce a whole bunch of great new songs live, then the band would be 1/6, the one being BTCS. Most of Crash had already been played quite a bit before recording, and all of UTTAD was.But those albums were crafted. It wasn't just "let's put any 12 songs we have right now on an album!" Off the top of my head, I want to say 4 or 5 Crash songs were recorded during the UTTAD sessions. They were cut because they probably wouldn't have fit on UTTAD. With the collection of songs they have right now, I don't really see how they could make a good, cohesive album. It would feel like a greatest hits album; but without any great hits.

So what I'm saying is basically I'm not sure what made you make this post, but I felt like responding as if it was directed to me. :lol

MistreatedLewis
03-22-2008, 09:52 PM
But those albums were crafted. It wasn't just "let's put any 12 songs we have right now on an album!" Off the top of my head, I want to say 4 or 5 Crash songs were recorded during the UTTAD sessions. They were cut because they probably wouldn't have fit on UTTAD. With the collection of songs they have right now, I don't really see how they could make a good, cohesive album. It would feel like a greatest hits album; but without any great hits.

So what I'm saying is basically I'm not sure what made you make this post, but I felt like responding as if it was directed to me. :lol

Well, that's why the thread was about there being *one* old song and not five ;)

jhuts612
03-22-2008, 09:52 PM
Does anyone like the the song Hold Me Down? I really like that one. I also like the untitled Jam on Live Trax Vol. 4.

darkfwank
03-22-2008, 10:02 PM
Nice topic Lewis. #40 (Yoshi lyrics)

born 1991
03-22-2008, 10:03 PM
I would love to see it too, but it has already been used in EWU (which I only just found out).

Well wasn't LIOG used in Grey Street?

spoot388
03-22-2008, 10:16 PM
Well wasn't LIOG used in Grey Street?


how so?

born 1991
03-22-2008, 10:33 PM
how so?

LIOG http://www.dmbtabs.com/song.php?sid=31

Grey Street http://www.dmbtabs.com/song.php?sid=66

The rhythm and order are only vaguely similar, but the chords in Grey Street's verse are identical to those in LIOG's jams.

Other than a couple chords though, EWU's not at all related to BUAH.

My point is that even though two songs are similar, it doesn't mean only one can be released. (It's highly unlikely that BUAH would be included anyway.:lorraine )

spoot388
03-22-2008, 10:47 PM
I think its more coincidence than anything else.

bigeyedfish190
03-22-2008, 10:57 PM
A few old songs would provide a benchmark for the rest of the release. I'm all for them recording Seek Up because I think it's the best song they still play not officialy released.

R2T

But whats the point of having it on a new album? They already play it, everyone knows it. Guarantee that after the first time you hear it, you'll think "nice, a studio Seek Up." and then after that you'll realize "why did they waste a spot on an album for this when it could have been a new song?"

Sure it would be cool to hear, but there really is no point of having a studio version of a song that was already played like 600 times.

R2T

If we were going to get another Stand Up, sure, then throw in a studio Seek Up and whatever other old song that hasn't been released yet. But there is actually some potential for a good, if not great album this time. Tim being in the studio with them should alone be enough to give this album a chance at being good. But they already have some promising stuff already made. This album could be really good.

R2T

/snob rant.

to answer the question, sugar will.

bubba40
03-23-2008, 12:17 AM
Sugar Will

spoot388
03-23-2008, 12:46 AM
R2T



R2T



R2T

/snob rant.

to answer the question, sugar will.



aaaaaaaaaannndd that Seek Up wasn't from the studio. its live.

good job genius :thumbsup




can someone help me, is this the part where i say "pwned"?

dmbfan4ever
03-23-2008, 12:53 AM
aaaaaaaaaannndd that Seek Up wasn't from the studio. its live.

good job genius :thumbsup




can someone help me, is this the part where i say "pwned"?
uhh....no...seek up on r2t is in the studio. I'm 99%

RobRoy286
03-23-2008, 01:13 AM
Yeah, Seek Up and Minarets from R2T are studio.

edit: http://dmbdiscography.com/bama001official.htm

dmbfan4ever
03-23-2008, 01:16 AM
Yeah, Seek Up and Minarets from R2T are studio.
true.

RobRoy286
03-23-2008, 01:18 AM
Wow, Jason I bet you feel like a total asshole now :thumbsup

bartender_man
03-23-2008, 01:38 AM
I don't want this touched until

a) Cavallo shows that he is capable and

b) the band shows that it is serious about making great studio records again.

I don't need a butchered Blue Water...



And that is why we don't need any old songs on there. The band will screw it up. Look at freaking hello again from the last album.. christ.

Joyride4136
03-23-2008, 01:41 AM
Yeah, Seek Up and Minarets from R2T are studio.

edit: http://dmbdiscography.com/bama001official.htm

:lol:lol owned.

TobiasClown
03-23-2008, 01:51 AM
aaaaaaaaaannndd that Seek Up wasn't from the studio. its live.

good job genius :thumbsup




can someone help me, is this the part where i say "pwned"?


:lol make sure you get your facts straight before you go around calling your own "pwn"

dmbmuskie
03-23-2008, 02:18 AM
R2T doesn't count. They rereleased plenty of stuff from it.

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 12:13 PM
R2T doesn't count. They rereleased plenty of stuff from it.

Not the studio stuff though.

BeQuietAndDrive
03-23-2008, 02:08 PM
aaaaaaaaaannndd that Seek Up wasn't from the studio. its live.

good job genius :thumbsup




can someone help me, is this the part where i say "pwned"?

Oh man :lol I absolutely love it when idiots make fools of themselves.

crashintonickdm
03-23-2008, 02:09 PM
36.

just because that could possibly mean the end of everyday. god that song sucks.

dre2142
03-23-2008, 02:14 PM
I find myself CONSTANTLY asking this question of you MistreatedLewis......can you answer your own question?

You constantly start threads like this, but never answer your own question.

And didnt they add crowd noise into R2T version of Seek Up? (hence why he thought it was live?)

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 02:20 PM
I find myself CONSTANTLY asking this question of you MistreatedLewis......can you answer your own question?

You constantly start threads like this, but never answer your own question.

And didnt they add crowd noise into R2T version of Seek Up? (hence why he thought it was live?)

:lol Did I forget to answer the question?

If I were fully confident in this album / process, I'd pick Blue Water without question.

I'd like to see them give Sugar Will the shot it deserves on this album. Especially with Tim being there. I'm much more interested in hearing what Tim has to say on this track.

dre2142
03-23-2008, 02:25 PM
Sugar Will for sure.

bubba40
03-23-2008, 06:32 PM
I'm pretty sure Tim would be indescribably beautiful on Sugar Will.

thestand
03-23-2008, 06:53 PM
You know what's funny? Going into this, as I've written before, I was fairly confident in Sugar Will at least being worked on. But I didn't want it to, because I wanted Trey on it, like it was going to be in 2005. But I honestly can say, even though I like Trey as a guitarist a solid 1000 times more than Tim, I think Tim would be better on Sugar Will than Trey.

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 06:56 PM
You know what's funny? Going into this, as I've written before, I was fairly confident in Sugar Will at least being worked on. But I didn't want it to, because I wanted Trey on it, like it was going to be in 2005. But I honestly can say, even though I like Trey as a guitarist a solid 1000 times more than Tim, I think Tim would be better on Sugar Will than Trey.

I just think Tim is a better fit for a DMB album than Trey would be. You never know though I guess

thestand
03-23-2008, 06:59 PM
Tim is a part of DMB, so he'll fit better. I just personally prefer Trey's style, and if he was a guest, it would actually sound like a guest, because it's bringing in a new sound to the mix. But when you step back and look at the situation, I'm debating whether to have Trey Anastasio or Tim Reynolds on a studio version of Sugar Will. Either way, I think we're good. :lol

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 07:08 PM
Tim is a part of DMB, so he'll fit better. I just personally prefer Trey's style, and if he was a guest, it would actually sound like a guest, because it's bringing in a new sound to the mix. But when you step back and look at the situation, I'm debating whether to have Trey Anastasio or Tim Reynolds on a studio version of Sugar Will. Either way, I think we're good. :lol

You haven't told me on a scale of 1 to 10 how sad Butch is that his "buddy" Tim is back yet

thestand
03-23-2008, 07:18 PM
Do you really think there was actually any bad blood? It was a heated argument that a few guys didn't want to get over. But everyone really has been fine with each other for a few years now. Tim has just outspokenly wanted to be his own man for the past few years. He gets angry when he's associated with DMB. But please, there's no anger or anything.

Butch knows he's a more important member of the band anyways... :rolleyes :lol

JMDMB
03-23-2008, 07:36 PM
Depending on the mood of the album, either Sweet Up and Down or Kind Intentions

PTstoy
03-23-2008, 07:58 PM
Tim is a part of DMB, so he'll fit better. I just personally prefer Trey's style, and if he was a guest, it would actually sound like a guest, because it's bringing in a new sound to the mix. But when you step back and look at the situation, I'm debating whether to have Trey Anastasio or Tim Reynolds on a studio version of Sugar Will. Either way, I think we're good. :lol

We are golden as long as they put effort into a studio sugar will...

Edit: no matter who guests on it

TobiasClown
03-23-2008, 08:49 PM
Depending on the mood of the album, either Sweet Up and Down or Kind Intentions

anyone like to post a version of Kind Intentions? ive never heard it. thanks

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 09:01 PM
Do you really think there was actually any bad blood? It was a heated argument that a few guys didn't want to get over. But everyone really has been fine with each other for a few years now. Tim has just outspokenly wanted to be his own man for the past few years. He gets angry when he's associated with DMB. But please, there's no anger or anything.

Butch knows he's a more important member of the band anyways... :rolleyes :lol

Ok. Just as long as you know that Butch is a completely uncreative uninspired hack, is all good :thumbsup

dre2142
03-23-2008, 09:14 PM
Pretty harsh...if thats true, what does that say about Carter and Tim? And especially Dave? And LeRoi for that matter?

MistreatedLewis
03-23-2008, 09:15 PM
Pretty harsh

Yeah, I'm hardkore anti-Butch, especially because of the past conflict with Tim

DMB only has room for one BT imo

Caveat Emperor
03-23-2008, 09:43 PM
I'd be really happy getting Crazy-Easy or SUAD on a new studio album.

I'd absolutely flip if they went out of nowhere and brought back "Deed is Done" , "True Reflections" or "People, People."

But, I'd place the odds of that happening at slightly better than an asteroid strike.

dre2142
03-23-2008, 09:47 PM
Yeah, I'm hardkore anti-Butch, especially because of the past conflict with Tim

DMB only has room for one BT imo

And details have been put out there about the conflict with Tim?

ZackR
03-24-2008, 01:27 AM
anyone like to post a version of Kind Intentions? ive never heard it. thanksHow about 2? :)

2.5.94 Soundcheck (http://mindshatter.com/dmbdl/dmb1994-02-05.sc.dsbd.shnf/)

1993 Demo (http://mindshatter.com/dmbdl/dmb1993-02-01.demo.flac16/)

TobiasClown
03-24-2008, 01:45 AM
How about 2? :)

2.5.94 Soundcheck (http://mindshatter.com/dmbdl/dmb1994-02-05.sc.dsbd.shnf/)

1993 Demo (http://mindshatter.com/dmbdl/dmb1993-02-01.demo.flac16/)


hey thanks

bigeyedfish190
03-24-2008, 02:28 PM
aaaaaaaaaannndd that Seek Up wasn't from the studio. its live.

good job genius :thumbsup




can someone help me, is this the part where i say "pwned"?

well...that was uncomfortable to watch, but anyway sorry if I came off a little hostile in my original post. I didn't mean it, and if I hadn't said it that way, you probably wouldn't have been so eager to "pwn" me, thus crashing and burning.

Seriously, I do enjoy your posts most of the time :)

DerekJTR2
03-24-2008, 02:45 PM
I'd absolutely flip if they went out of nowhere and brought back "Deed is Done" , "True Reflections" or "People, People."

But, I'd place the odds of that happening at slightly better than an asteroid strike.

Where does this desire for True Reflections come from!???

It's recorded and released. Dave sings on it. Why in gods name would Boyd want to rerecord it? Dave says one day "Boyd you suck Ima sing this one. Deal with it."

Deed is Done would be nice on the next Dave Solo Album

sonofsuns34
03-24-2008, 02:50 PM
if they made a song that was the bastard child of Gas into Fire and Dreamed I killed God that would make me happy

basketballjack
03-24-2008, 02:55 PM
the more and more i listen to kill the king, I love that song they should bring that back on the new album

DerekJTR2
03-24-2008, 02:58 PM
the more and more i listen to kill the king, I love that song they should bring that back on the new album

This sucks. We'll never know if Dave said, wow this song blows (which he hopefully said about Fall Off the Roof). Or he could have said I love this song, lets put it away and work it out in the studio instead of live. Unlikely, I'm sure, but we've got no idea :mad

Caveat Emperor
03-24-2008, 03:08 PM
Where does this desire for True Reflections come from!???

It's recorded and released. Dave sings on it. Why in gods name would Boyd want to rerecord it? Dave says one day "Boyd you suck Ima sing this one. Deal with it."

Deed is Done would be nice on the next Dave Solo Album

I've been listening to Listener Supported a lot lately -- it was a neat tune, I'd not mind to see it back with the band.

dreamingtree_34
03-24-2008, 03:13 PM
Yeah, I'm hardkore anti-Butch, especially because of the past conflict with Tim

DMB only has room for one BT imo


yes what is this past conflict? is it the same thing about tim taking attention from the rest of the band or whatever?

as for butch i have no problem with him save his jimi thing abominations

DerekJTR2
03-24-2008, 03:14 PM
I've been listening to Listener Supported a lot lately -- it was a neat tune, I'd not mind to see it back with the band.

Just wish it'd come back live. Only been played once in the past 4 and a half years. It was recorded for Crash, didn't make it and the Boyd used it. I don't think we'll ever see it recorded again but it'd be great to have on a handful of shows this summer definitely

CapnHani06
03-24-2008, 07:11 PM
"Looking at You", "Dreamed I Killed God", or "JTR" to name two more than one :lol

but if i were to choose only one, it'd be "Looking at You"...what a fantastic little tune :thumbsup

number4ty1
03-24-2008, 07:18 PM
Get in Line !

End thread !

elconguero
03-25-2008, 07:45 PM
$o will a new album. $o I'm not really $ure why thi$ is ne$$e$$ary. I just don't see the point in saying it's just for money. I mean, if we do it, it'll probably be one of the best things they've ever done. I mean, just think of what they have that we don't have. They have a few versions of Granny, a few versions of #40, a few versions of Kind Intentions, a few versions of Get in Line, a few #36, Deed is Done, Don't Burn the Pig, Little Thing, MacHead, Sugar Will, Crazy Easy, JTR (mixed & mastered), Monkey Man (m&m), BYAH (m&M), SUAD (m&M). And those are only the things we know about. It would be a service to the fans, and one of, if not THE coolest things they've ever done.

7 years later, and this song still bores me to tears.

their vault looks like their best album. i wish i could be a fly on the wall to know what they are thinking at some of their song choices.


oh and seek up was studio on R2T. i would take a studio one sweet world or recently though. but not if it removes another. just if they want to add it on for fucks sake.

elconguero
03-25-2008, 07:47 PM
to answer the real question though. either sugar will or blue water.

dmbmuskie
03-26-2008, 01:38 AM
Me and Her would be a nice closer. I'm blown away by it everytime I hear it.

sir iggius
03-26-2008, 01:41 AM
Sugar Will

Rockhound18
03-26-2008, 10:24 AM
SUAD or STJL is what I would love to get my hands on. Regardless, I'm excited that a new album is on the way soon.

rnieves
03-26-2008, 10:46 AM
Definitely Sugar Will.

marco j
03-26-2008, 11:25 AM
I think these songs all fit amazingly well together......

Crazy Easy
JTR
SUAD
Light Lift Me Up
Falling Off The Roof
Blue Water
Kill The King
Shotgun
Sugarwill
Loving Wings

bbianca1982
03-26-2008, 11:49 AM
People, People

GoodDayIIDie
03-26-2008, 01:09 PM
I think these songs all fit amazingly well together......

Crazy Easy
JTR
SUAD
Light Lift Me Up
Falling Off The Roof
Blue Water
Kill The King
Shotgun
Sugarwill
Loving Wings


Yeah, when you put together a group of songs like that, it makes me think that this band could just get back in the studio and kick some ass. If they only would come to grips with their other shitty music.