PDA

View Full Version : Best of Spring 2k2 Compilation!!


dr9553
07-26-2002, 06:18 AM
Here is the deal folks. Since summer shows seem to be getting released slower than the spring ones, I have decided to put together a Best of Spring 2002 Compilation. For this I am going to need some help from you the viewers at home. Go to:

http://www.geocities.com/dmbtour2k2/vote2.html

and vote for the songs and versions of the songs you want on the CD's. In about a week or so, I will tally up the votes and come up with a track list. From there I might need some help coming up with the track order, but we will worry about that when we get there.

All the sources I will be using will be the ones used by the late great 2002 Trading Network. These source files can be sound at:

http://www.geocities.com/dmbtour2k2/series1.html
and
http://www.geocities.com/dmbtour2k2/series2.html

If you have another source for the song you want that you think is better then what I have, let me know.. I will see what I can do.

Well that about sums up the details of my little project. So I am asking you... PLEASE GO AND VOTE!!

*UPDATE 1*

The dust has started to settle a bit, and some things have become abundently clear...... LIKE DISC 1!

01. Intro 05-29 01:16.742
02. Crush 05-29 11:42.094
03. #40 (tease) 05-16 00:28.760
04. Seek Up 05-19 23:10.823
05. I Did It 05-28 03:52.879
06. Granny 05-28 05:49.247
07. Song That Jane Likes 05-28 05:14.605
08. Jimi Thing 04-27 13:30.542

Disc 1 Total: 65:05.69

*UPDATE 2*

Out of the dark something has emerged... DISC 2!

Now I know there wer complaints about disc 1 containing a lot of MSG songs, well you will be happy to see this disc only has 1 :)

01. Grace is Gone (tease) 05-13 02:08.335
02. One Sweet World 05-29 08:39.632
03. Recently 05-12 03:04.379
04. You Never Know 04-07 06:29.815
05. Waste 05-10 03:47.550
06. Impromptu Jam 04-04 03:14.885
07. Satellite 05-15 05:10.975
08. Cry Freedom (tease) 05-18 00:53.488
09. #36/Everyday 05-19 07:03.724
10. #41 04-20 32:12.998

Disc 2 Total: 72:45.78

Disc 3 is a ways off as far as show dates. Of the 35-40 songs left to choose from many have a 2-4 way tie for the date.

*UPDATE 3*
Small update. Voting is coming a long well.

After careful listining to Disc 1 I have noticed somethings that I have found unsatisfactory. Mainly tiny mistakes on my part. SO basically... Disc 1 as it stands now may not be the final version. When I return to Chicago on sat. I will be checking it out.
The song order or dates probably wont change.. unless i feel strongly about the input given fromthis site. I will be making an update Sat evening sometime about the statis of disc 1.

With that said. Please do continue to enjoy the compilation so far. The problems I have found are just because I am anal about the audio stuff. It still sounds damn good!

*UPDATE 4*

Tracks should be fixed.. one minor set list change.. the Jimi Thing on disc one is now the 4-27 version. My own personal preference was used on this one.. I am allowed 1 or 2 on here :)

*UPDATE 5*

Small update. Voting is now over. Final votes will be added up and work on the remaining discs will start tomorrow (8/9) so look for more updates to come on the remaining discs.

A BIG THANK YOU goes out to all of you who have voted so far, and to those of you who havent... it's too late. Look for a possible summer compilation. I am not too sure about this yet. I will see how everyone likes this one before I make an plans for a summer comp.

Donald

dr9553
07-26-2002, 05:51 PM
Votes are rolling nicely.. keep em coming.. top!

Donald

dr9553
07-26-2002, 10:02 PM
Come on people.. keep voting if you have not, lets keep this topped to... the more input the better the comp.

Donald

dr9553
07-28-2002, 02:41 PM
Top

dr9553
07-29-2002, 01:35 AM
keep it topped people :)

dwj21
07-29-2002, 06:02 PM
top

onesweetworld15
07-29-2002, 06:16 PM
That first disc is more than half MSG...there were better Crush's than MSG...

Peace

Michael

urth
07-29-2002, 06:27 PM
people voted for IDI? I just kept it blank

wicketjedi
07-29-2002, 07:16 PM
Originally posted by onesweetworld15
That first disc is more than half MSG...there were better Crush's than MSG...

Peace

Michael

true, all the i did it's are basically the same, soo maybe at least change that one, it doesn't matter that it has to be that date...and then we can get rid of some of the MSG on that disc

dmb4life2000
07-29-2002, 08:19 PM
the jimi thing has to be changed to the 4/27/02 show because that is the best version out of any that have ever been played.

wicketjedi
07-29-2002, 08:21 PM
Originally posted by dmb4life2000
the jimi thing has to be changed to the 4/27/02 show because that is the best version out of any that have ever been played.

also agree, after being at both 4.23 and 4.27, 4.27 was much better

dwj21
07-29-2002, 11:29 PM
you guys dont understand, it was all voted on and donald is just tallying up the votes and making the compilation out of the songs that had the most votes, not everyone will agree which nites had the best versions, so everyone cn a little of something, just a quick noteand to top this thing

peace
darron

IAmScotty2Hotty
07-29-2002, 11:39 PM
Donald,
Thanks for all of your time putting this compilation together!! Let me know when its done so i can get one via B&P or Trade. I hope my input will help with the voting.
Peace,
Scotty2Hotty
scotty2hotty2969@aol.com

dr9553
07-30-2002, 12:30 AM
Originally posted by dwj21
you guys dont understand, it was all voted on and donald is just tallying up the votes and making the compilation out of the songs that had the most votes, not everyone will agree which nites had the best versions, so everyone cn a little of something, just a quick noteand to top this thing

peace
darron

This is correct. The resason these songs have been taken from these shwos is because they were with out a doubt a clear winner. I have been only taking songs that were clearly ahead by 10 or more votes. That is why I am holding off right now on some of the rest. Disc 2 is done as of now. That means there will eb 1 or two more left. I still have 40 songs or so to get on the comp. With the way it has been looking, focus has moved away from the MSG shows, and to some of the earlier ones.

Thank You for your votes and input. This project is moving along nicely!

Donald

viking7
07-30-2002, 03:03 AM
ya gotta vote for some of beckers 4-29 show not only cuz of the sound but tracks like "raven" and "what you are" are tight and sound great. give em a listen.

dmbrhs
07-30-2002, 01:43 PM
Originally posted by onesweetworld15
That first disc is more than half MSG...there were better Crush's than MSG...

Peace

Michael


...like the 5-24 with ERIC KRASNO!!!!!! That was sick!!

$Texas
07-30-2002, 02:48 PM
voted ... good luck w/ the comp!!!

dr9553
07-31-2002, 10:35 AM
Top

onesweetworld15
07-31-2002, 04:42 PM
How will "Waste" work in the middle of a set? I'm just a little curious.

Peace

Michael

ssamadhi97
07-31-2002, 04:57 PM
Originally posted by dmbrhs
...like the 5-24 with ERIC KRASNO!!!!!! That was sick!!
*seconds*

:D

dr9553
08-01-2002, 12:59 AM
Originally posted by onesweetworld15
How will "Waste" work in the middle of a set? I'm just a little curious.


It did.. dont worry about it.

Donald

dr9553
08-05-2002, 02:31 AM
top

bbycrei
08-05-2002, 11:07 PM
Its also wierd how some of the songs from 4-10 aren't mentioned. Especially LIOG. personally, the best i have ever heard. I also didn't see Too Much, Raven, Gray Street, PNP -> Rapunzel, WWYS, DIDO, DDTW, just to name a few more.

onesweetworld15
08-05-2002, 11:33 PM
I'm sorry but some of this really does not make sense setlist order wise. Here are things that stick out in my mind

How do you put a Dave solo song in the middle of a show? I don't see Waste mixing with either the Impromptu Jam or YNK.

Seek Up has only been second in a show once in the past 3 years, 8-27-00. I would think you put it near the 5 or 6 slot or the opener. That's where it has been commonly played.

I don't get a couple of the teases. (GIG)-->OSW should work OK. But why is there a #40 tease right after the opener? This hasn't been done near this slot but once or twice I believe and hasn't been done since 12-19-98. Why is the Cry Freedom tease a) in the middle of a set and b) before Everyday? I can see why you put it before Everyday if it had lyrics because they kind of have the same topic/message w/ #36, but there were no lyrics in the tease and the chords are nothing alike...

If this isn't intended to be like Dream Setlist was where the songs are supposed to be in order of an actual setlist, then forgive this post.

Don't get me wrong, I'm not criticizing you in anyway. The choices for most of the songs are great. I just don't see how some of this works.

I've made up a setlist for a compilation before and I feel I have an OK understanding of patterns in certain tours and order of songs in certain tours, but I would just like an explanation thats all.

*The main reason for this post is to learn where these patterns and fades and mid-set teases come from because I'm very interested.

Peace

Michael

dr9553
08-06-2002, 02:31 AM
Thanks for the post. I sent ya an e-mail about the order of things. Basically.. i have just been kinda doing my own thing on the setlist part.. making it as I go and seeing if it sounds good.

And about why there are some dates missing from the voting is because, after consulting my thinktank, i decided to narrow the dates down.. I took a look at my tally sheet, and I took the date with the highest amount of votes, and then any other dates within 3-4 votes of the highest and picked those date.

Donald

BobR
08-06-2002, 10:31 AM
Donald:

if I go and re-download disc one track one will I have the whole thing? I had it all dl'd when you decided to change it a bit. I'd love to start serving it on my server once I'm sure it's the way you want it.

also, you should leave 4-23's Jimi Thing but use Josh Popejoy's source :)

dr9553
08-06-2002, 02:15 PM
I have to retrack it. I had to edit my fades and stuff but this is the final version of Disc 1. I am going to do a final review of Disc 2 either today or tomorrow, to make sure it is fine. It sounded fine when i was listining to it earlier, but i want to be sure. I will let you know when I get it all finished.

Donald

P.S. THank you again for serving it for me. Greatly appreciated!

Drewzilla
08-06-2002, 06:56 PM
how can you go about getting this comp; once it is finalized? it sounds great

dmbkristin
08-06-2002, 07:00 PM
You should add 5.23.02's Wynona to the voting... If you haven't heard it (Fulton's source), you should! :D

dr9553
08-07-2002, 01:36 AM
Well to answer the question about spreading the compilation. I personally will be donig a B+P of the compilation once it is finished. Plus I am working n getting it uploaded to some people to help me spread it online.

Donald

dmb4life2000
08-07-2002, 01:59 PM
Originally posted by dr9553

*UPDATE 4*

Tracks should be fixed.. one minor set list change.. the Jimi Thing on disc one is now the 4-27 version. My own personal preference was used on this one.. I am allowed 1 or 2 on here :)

Donald

finally a compelation with the 4-27-02 jimi thing on it

dr9553
08-09-2002, 12:52 AM
top

BobR
08-13-2002, 10:25 AM
TOP

Discs 1 and 2 are on my server now! Info is on the servers page.

-Bob