Quote:
Originally Posted by recentlyJTR41
Gibson played in the playoffs 3 times.
Maddux was in the playoffs 13 different times.
Not really fair to compare those two records with each other.
|
The point of my post was not that Gibson is better than Maddux, but that given those comparisons, Gibson at a minimum belongs in the discussion with top 10 pitchers.
Also, Gibson was at his PEAK during 6 of those 9 playoff games so yes, it may be a slightly unfair comparison to Maddux 13 playoff appearances.