2017: Best Released Versions Poll - Under The Table And Dreaming

[chadizzy1]

We are through everything except the big three now. Starting with Under The Table And Dreaming, this album has the most live releases of songs from an album. The results of this one should be interesting!

Poll link:
https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1F...rm?usp=sf_link

You can post your links in a reply, but also vote in the poll. I think I got every version, but in the event that I missed one you can note in your reply that I forgot your favorite version and list what it is. But I think I got them all.

[chadizzy1]

My picks:

#34 - Weekend on the Rocks (9/10/05)

Ants Marching - Live Trax 13 (6/7/08)
- Love the D&T Style intro on this one

Best of What’s Around - DMBLive Trax (7/28/92)
- I really like the slower tempo on this one

Jimi Thing - Luther College (D&T 2/6/96)
- I don’t like long versions of this song, so when I want to hear it I usually stick to a short version

Lover Lay Down - WH10Vol2 (10/29/98)

Dancing Nancies - Live Trax 29 (6/1/13)
- This is one that I like newer versions of

Pay For What You Get - WH8Vol3 (9/27/94)
- I dig Roi on this one

Rhyme & Reason - Live Trax 5 (8/23/95)

Satellite - DMBLive Academy *Acoustic* (4/5/95)
- Such a beautiful version of this song

Typical Situation - Live Trax 8 (8/7/04)
- My favorite version of this song - Roi kills it. I think this is also one of my top live tracks from the band’s entire catalog.

Warehouse - Live Trax 8 (8/7/04
- I love the jam on this one

What Would You Say - Central Park (9/24/03)
- This has always been my go to for this song.

[crashintonickdm]

#34 - the return in 2005
Pay for what you get - LT08
Satellite - RR95
Lover lay down - LT31
Best of what's around - warehouse disc from 2004
Rhyme and reason - red rocks 95
Warehouse - 11/30/98
Ants - gorge 02
Jimi thing - Central Park
Typical situation - LT8
Dancing nancies - RR95
What would you say - they're all the same. But mine has to be a Roi version

[chadizzy1]

Warehouse from the 1998 DMBLive in Philly is doing pretty well so far. Went back to relisten to it, it's a nice version!

[hensleytyler44]

#34 - WH5v10 - My go to version of this song, love that whole disc
Ants Marching - LT29 - such an epic ending to that show, I'm a little biased because I was there
Best of What's Around - LT37 - without a doubt the best version of this song, so freaking good
Dancing Nancies - LT29 - First time this had opened a show in a long time, it was incredible
Jimi Thing - LT1 - Tim's solo at the end of this is nuts
Lover Lay Down - LT8v1 - I listen to this WH disc a lot so that version always comes to mind
Pay for What You Get - LT17 - I like that you can't hear the crowd on this version lol
Rhyme & Reason - LT7 - Just my go to version
Satellite - LT30 - Roi's solo at the beginning is simply amazing, like BOWA, I feel this is without a doubt the best version
Typical Situation - LT16 - Roi sounds great on this version
Warehouse - LT29 - My bias is showing again but I chose this one because it sounded so good in person
What Would You Say - The Gorge 02 - Had to go with the Gorge, that is the version I hear in my head anytime I think of this song

[miro_eight]

Lover Lay Down from WH 10.2 is just amazing. This should win easily.

[crashintonickdm]

Will results for any of these ever be posted?

[chadizzy1]

Originally Posted by crashintonickdm

Will results for any of these ever be posted?

After the last poll is completed I'm going to make a thread and post them all in one place (results for every poll done so far)

[chadizzy1]

Results so far:

Ties:

#34 - Weekend on the Rocks & WH5Vol10
BOWA - WH8Vol1 and LT30
PFWYG - LT5, LT30, LT2008
Rhyme & Reason - DMBLive Philly & Red Rocks
Typical - LT8 and LT7
Warehouse - Central Park and DMBLive Philly
WWYS - Central Park, Piedmont and Atlantic City

Commanding lead:

Dancing Nancies - Central Park
Jimi Thing - Central Park
Satellite - LT30

Ants and Lover Lay Down could go any direction - lots of votes for different versions.

[Todefy]

#34 - Warehouse 8 Volume 7
Ants Marching - Live Trax 3
Best Of What's Around - Warehouse 8 Volume 1
Dancing Nancies - Central Park
Jimi Thing - Central Park
Lover Lay Down - Live Trax 33/Gorge/Warehouse 8 Volume 1
Rhyme & Reason - Live Trax 5
Satellite - Live at Luther College
Typical Situation - Live Trax 34
Warehouse - Central Park
What Would You Say - DMBLive 3/26/1994

[crashintonickdm]

Great choice with satellite. Luther is incredible

[CrashTheStone41]

Wish there was at least 1 1993 release of #34

[chadizzy1]

Originally Posted by CrashTheStone41

Wish there was at least 1 1993 release of #34

There's a soundboard of the Big League Chew show from 1993, and it has a #34 on it (a version with lyrics). I uploaded that show the other day in MP3 format:

Originally Posted by chadizzy1

3/23/93 - DMB - Trax (Charlottesville, VA) "Big League Chew" - Download Link
(Album Art)
(Taper Credit)

[CrashTheStone41]

Originally Posted by chadizzy1

There's a soundboard of the Big League Chew show from 1993, and it has a #34 on it (a version with lyrics). I uploaded that show the other day in MP3 format:

Sweet. Literally the show I wanted to listen to. I at the setlisted names of the songs according to the almanac.


Thanks, mannnnn

[dpduke5173]

#34-WOTR
Ants Marching- LT3
Best of What's Around- LT2
Dancing Nancies- Central Park
Jimi Thing-Central Park
Lover Lay Down-LT37
Rhyme & Reason-LT13
Satellite-LT31
Typical Situation-LT8
Warehouse-Central Park
What Would You Say-LT2

[CrashTheStone41]

Favorite WWYS is from Masquerade Night. Even though it has a musical mishap at the beginning, the end where Dave is singing and directing the band is incredible.

[chadizzy1]

Results so far:

#34 - Weekend on the Rocks (9/10/05) - 54.5%
Ants Marching - LT13 (6/7/08) - 22.7%
Best of What’s Around - WH8Vol1 (7/11/04) - 22.7%
Dancing Nancies - Central Park (9/24/03) - 29.2%
Jimi Thing - Central Park (9/24/03) - 36.4%
Lover Lay Down - Red Rocks 95 (8/15/95) - 29.2%
Rhyme & Reason - Central Park (9/24/03) - 27.3%
Satellite - LT30 (8/16/93) - 25%
Typical Situation - LT8 (8/7/04) - 28.6%
Warehouse - Central Park (9/24/03) - 25%
What Would You Say - Piedmont Park (9/8/07) - 28.6%

Ties
Pay For What You Get - LT13 (6/7/08) & LT5 (8/23/95) - both at 21.2% each

[chadizzy1]

Results so far:

#34 - Weekend on the Rocks (9/10/05) - 56.5%
Ants Marching - LT13 (6/7/08) - 21.7%
Dancing Nancies - Central Park (9/24/03) - 28%
Jimi Thing - Central Park (9/24/03) - 39.1%
Lover Lay Down - Red Rocks 95 (8/15/95) - 28%
Rhyme & Reason - Central Park (9/24/03) - 26.1%
Satellite - LT30 (8/16/93) - 23.8%
Typical Situation - LT8 (8/7/04) - 21.8%
Warehouse - Central Park (9/24/03) - 24%
What Would You Say - Piedmont Park (9/8/07) - 31.8%

Ties
Pay For What You Get - LT13 (6/7/08) & LT5 (8/23/95) - both at 20% each
Best of What’s Around - WH8Vol1 (7/11/04) and LT2 (9/12/04)

[camptravisr]

Originally Posted by miro_eight

Lover Lay Down from WH 10.2 is just amazing. This should win easily.

Give LT 5 another chance, that's one of my favorite released tracks by the band.

[sean52692]

#34 - Warehouse 5 Volume 10
Ants Marching - Live Trax 3
The Best of What's Around - Red Rocks '95
Dancing Nancies - Live Trax 3
Jimi Thing - Live Trax 1
Lover Lay Down - Live Trax 31
Pay For What You Get - Live Trax 5
Rhyme & Reason - Live Trax 21
Satellite - Live Trax 30
Typical Situation - Luther College
Warehouse - Live Trax 12
What Would You Say - Live in Chicago

[Jan-Willem]

WWYS Live in Chicago. That Maceo Parker solo is so funky


Verzonden vanaf mijn iPad met Tapatalk

[drop2d]

I haven't taken part in any of these polls bc there's not a lot of songs that stand out to me. But the WWYS on the WH disc is pure fire.

[chadizzy1]

Originally Posted by drop2d

I haven't taken part in any of these polls bc there's not a lot of songs that stand out to me. But the WWYS on the WH disc is pure fire.

That's why I didn't have it required that people vote on every song. I left it open - so people could come in and vote on one version, or every version.

[chadizzy1]

Results so far:

#34 - WOTR still winning
Ants Marching - LT3 has overtaken LT20
Dancing Nancies - CP still in the lead
Jimi Thing - CP still in the lead
Lover Lay Down - RR95 has taken the lead
PFWYG - LT13 leading over LT5
Rhyme & Reason - CP has the lead
Satellite - LT30 with the lead
Typical Situation - LT8 in the lead
Warehouse - CP in the lead
WWYS - Piedmont in the lead, CP close behind

Ties:
BOWA - Three way tie! WH8Vol1, LT2 and RR95.