Quote:
Originally Posted by rantingthespian
Sorry, but just because something is supported by a majority doesn't make it a fact.
|
This is entirely incorrect.
The "majority"
created the moniker "Big Three" based upon the fact that it's almost unanimously agreed upon across the fanbase that UTTAD, Crash and BTCS are all excellent albums (most consider them the band's three best albums). If you ask someone what the "Big Four" consists of, nearly all responses will include the three aforementioned albums, plus either BWGK, BS, or LWS; hence, there is no consensus as to what makes up the Big Four, and therefore there is no Big Four.
You can like another album as much, and it's great that you do, but just because you personally feel that way doesn't mean a Big Four exists.
Quote:
Originally Posted by jray1823
Yet everyone is in love with Lillywhite sessions.... Same effing songs minus the two in red and the shitty lyrics from Kit Kat Jam. Sure, where are you going sucks, but I'm pretty sure YNK cancels that out.
- "Busted Stuff" – 3:48
- "Grey Street" – 5:08
- "Where are you going" – 3:53
- "You Never Know" – 5:54
- "Captain" – 3:46
- "Raven" – 5:38
- "Grace Is Gone" – 4:38
- "Kit Kat Jam" – 3:35
- "Digging a Ditch" – 4:47
- "Big Eyed Fish" – 5:04
- "Bartender" – 8:32
|
There is no comparison between LWS and BS.
First, look at the unique songs -- JTR, Sweet Up & Down and Monkey Man vs. YNK and WAYG. YNK is a great song, but you're comparing three great songs to one great song and one below-average (at best) song.
Second, the overall production quality of the unfinished LWS trumps BS across the board. The latter just sounds too polished, while LWS sounds honest and, most importantly, more like DMB.
Lastly, most songs are better on LWS than BS, with some exceptions.
Point being, you can't just look at the songs and say they're the same, because they're not in the least.