Who is the historically better QB: Manning vs Brady

[pathetic]

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

Not down playing. The injuries during the game and Sherman are facts.

Brady played great looked good in the 4th quarter

Who cares about the injuries? It's football. You play to win on that day with what you have. Continue the excuse train. It's not going to make this thread topic relevant again though.

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

Oh I don't know about making a fool out of myself because I like Manning.

I like Tom Brady to, great QB.

I like how you are working awful grammar into this melt. Well played.

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Who cares about the injuries? It's football. You play to win on that day with what you have. Continue the excuse train. It's not going to make this thread topic relevant again though.

Didn't use it as an excuse, just pointed out facts

When the injuries occurred Brady's numbers improved. Seahawks were still on the goal line to win the game, I thought made the correct call and Butler made a great play

I mean what else do you want me to say?

[rickyh24]

Fact: injuries happen in the NFL. Groundbreaking stuff.

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

I like how you are working awful grammar into this melt. Well played.

New iPhone user here. I always had swipe on a cell phone. Please forgive me grammar police

Also pointing out grammar is the clear sign of a melt

[rickyh24]

Dmbstandup did you destroy your Samsung Galaxy?

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Fact: injuries happen in the NFL. Groundbreaking stuff.

LoL yup they happen.

Is it groundbreaking that injuries can affect the outcome of a game?

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Dmbstandup did you destroy your Samsung Galaxy?

Traded it in, nothing to hide

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

LoL yup they happen.

Is it groundbreaking that injuries can affect the outcome of a game?

Remember when talib went down in the afc championship game? Poor pats...Amirite?

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Remember when talib went down in the afc championship game? Poor pats...Amirite?

Yea. Clearly changed the landscape of the game. It did

[pathetic]

Justin, do you think the pats should have atleast another ring or two if it wasn't for severe injuries to welker, gronk, and talib over the years?

[gripes81]

Originally Posted by pathetic

Justin, do you think the pats should have atleast another ring or two if it wasn't for severe injuries to welker, gronk, and talib over the years?

Brady is single handedly responsible for any and all success the patriots have and will ever have so injuries to anyone other than him shouldn't matter #bradyisthegoat #bradyisgod #onhisnutsallday

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by pathetic

Justin, do you think the pats should have atleast another ring or two if it wasn't for severe injuries to welker, gronk, and talib over the years?

If Gronk was healthy in the Giants super bowl? Absolutely

In that AFC Championship game? No the Broncos were a better team, Pats over achieved that year. And got tomato cans going into and in the playoffs

[DMBstandUP1984]

I haven't dug my heels in this much to defend Manning in awhile. I hate the Seahawks to

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by gripes81

#bradyisthegoat

Removed the parts that don't make sense for you.

[rickyh24]

I do like how this thread has pretty much just turned into the last few manning supporters in this debate melting though. Really no other direction for it to go.

[jjr4884]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

Yea against a crippled Seahawks defense.

I'd hardly call it the same team.

Why you getting so salty. Pats fans so sensitive. The anger because I picked someone over your precious Tom Brady. Hilarious

That wasn't salty at all, just putting some facts up. And lol at you calling the Seacawks crippled.... why because everyone whined about being hurt after the game? Come on now.

Lets call a spade a spade here, Tom Brady would have never lost 43-8 in a super bowl. Not. Even. Close.

Now go change your panties, maybe you are the sensitive one if i can't talk to you in a little more of a "direct" fashion. Feelings don't exist on the internets.

[MOWJO8185]

I wonder, if Brady plays for 3-4 additional years at his current level of play after Manning retires, if Manning will even have the regular season stats to lean on anymore in this argument.

[gripes81]

Originally Posted by rickyh24

Removed the parts that don't make sense for you.

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by jjr4884

That wasn't salty at all, just putting some facts up. And lol at you calling the Seacawks crippled.... why because everyone whined about being hurt after the game? Come on now.

Lets call a spade a spade here, Tom Brady would have never lost 43-8 in a super bowl. Not. Even. Close.

Now go change your panties, maybe you are the sensitive one if i can't talk to you in a little more of a "direct" fashion. Feelings don't exist on the internets.

LoL k got it

[pathetic]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

If Gronk was healthy in the Giants super bowl? Absolutely

In that AFC Championship game? No the Broncos were a better team, Pats over achieved that year. And got tomato cans going into and in the playoffs

ok DanS

[thebridge15]

wonder what would have happened had manning had to face a QB other than rex grossman in the super bowl

[pathetic]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

If Gronk was healthy in the Giants super bowl? Absolutely

well, then they got it last year as a makeup. just had to beat the best D brady's ever faced. anti-tomato can defense

[jjr4884]

Originally Posted by pathetic

Justin, do you think the pats should have atleast another ring or two if it wasn't for severe injuries to welker, gronk, and talib over the years?

Honestly, I truly believe we should have 6. The AFC lost to the Colts in 06 stunggggggggggggggggg really bad, especially because we would have absolutely destroyed the bears in the SB. That game was 21-6 at the half. The colts just killed it 2nd half and we completely fell apart.

Also, that Tyree catch was luck. That is all. I'm not making excuses, but when you look at that play, the holding that wasn't called, that miracle catch... yea... On a more realistic side... we under performed that entire game, and the giant's d-line had our number. We had the players to control the game, we just weren't prepared. In no way shape of form am I saying that the Giants didn't earn that game, they did, and then some.

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by thebridge15

wonder what would have happened had manning had to face a QB other than rex grossman in the super bowl

Hard to say since they are not on the field at the same time.


Beat a good defense though

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by thebridge15

wonder what would have happened had manning had to face a QB other than rex grossman in the super bowl

[pathetic]

Originally Posted by jjr4884

Honestly, I truly believe we should have 6. The AFC lost to the Colts in 06 stunggggggggggggggggg really bad, especially because we would have absolutely destroyed the bears in the SB. That game was 21-6 at the half. The colts just killed it 2nd half and we completely fell apart.

Also, that Tyree catch was luck. That is all. I'm not making excuses, but when you look at that play, the holding that wasn't called, that miracle catch... yea... On a more realistic side... we under performed that entire game, and the giant's d-line had our number. We had the players to control the game, we just weren't prepared. In no way shape of form am I saying that the Giants didn't earn that game, they did, and then some.

i was in college in Chicago watching everyone celebrate the bears going to the superbowl and that loss hurt just as bad as the first superbowl to the giants. pats had a chance to be heavily favored in their 4th superbowl in 6 years.

[DMBstandUP1984]

Originally Posted by pathetic

i was in college in Chicago watching everyone celebrate the bears going to the superbowl and that loss hurt just as bad as the first superbowl to the giants. pats had a chance to be heavily favored in their 4th superbowl in 6 years.

I was home and all I remember is a ball just off the finger tips of Wayne that was primed to get picked off....it felt like slow motion watching the ball land.

Ending up being a PI on the play but that 5 seconds was suspenseful to say the least

I wanted to go out and celebrate, remembered I lived in Massachusetts, went to bed instead

[jjr4884]

Originally Posted by DMBstandUP1984

I was home and all I remember is a ball just off the finger tips of Wayne that was primed to get picked off....it felt like slow motion watching the ball land.

Ending up being a PI on the play but that 5 seconds was suspenseful to say the least

I wanted to go out and celebrate, remembered I lived in Massachusetts, went to bed instead

hahahaaahahah cracks me up, smart choice