Who is the greatest QB ever?

[Rebecca De Mornay]

the only guy playing right now that has a chance to challenge brady or monatna is Rodgers, IMO.

manning is out of the running.
manning deserved more than 1 title though.

[thebridge15]

I'm pretty positive that people weren't thinking the colts defenses were bad back when 2005-2010 were actually occurring. only after a period are people saying that peyton didn't have a good team around him (which in nfl arguments means he's better)

[hailtopitt]

Originally Posted by Rebecca De Mornay

the only guy playing right now that has a chance to challenge brady or monatna is Rodgers, IMO.

manning is out of the running.
manning deserved more than 1 title though.

Luck & Wilson have a slight chance if either of them approach the 3 & 4 SB territory

Rodgers too of course

[kmh1234]

OP is a Yankee and Patriots fan? Wonder if he is rooting for the Cavs this year?

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by kmh1234

OP is a Yankee and Patriots fan? Wonder if he is rooting for the Cavs this year?

You know the Yankees suck right?

[YankeesDMB41]

it's so great being a yankee fan! watching a team of 40 year olds go .500...such a frontrunner!

[kmh1234]

Made the name in '09 - how'd they do that year?

I can probably guess when the Avatar was added.

[ukcanes]

Dan Marino. Yup I'm biased

[neumdogg]

Originally Posted by YankeesDMB41

it's so great being a yankee fan! watching a team of 40 year olds go .500...such a frontrunner!

Must be hard rooting for a team that has 27 WS titles.

[ukcanes]

It's impossible to feel bad for a Yanks fan unless they're 4 years old.

[Rebecca De Mornay]

how did dan marino even get on this list?

[mthawk07]

Joe Montana. Great tackler, too.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Qpj73xhGvmM

[scrock25]

Originally Posted by neumdogg

Must be hard rooting for a team that has 27 WS titles.

That's all in the past, Paulie. It doesn't count.

You realize that there are rules for Tailgating, correct??

[Lee3691]

Bradshaw, Staubach, and Starr should of been replaced with Elway, Graham and Steve Young

[scrock25]

Yeah, right... they should of.

What does that even mean??

[pathetic]

steve young? really?

[Lee3691]

Originally Posted by scrock25

Yeah, right... they should of.

What does that even mean??

That one was for you.

Originally Posted by pathetic

steve young? really?

Steve Young was great. He was completing 65% of his passes when the league average was under 60%. Also one of the first mobile QBs that could throw.

[pathetic]

of course he was great, he's a HOFer. we're talking about the greatest QB of all time. he's not even the greatest QB of his franchise's history

[Lee3691]

Originally Posted by pathetic

of course he was great, he's a HOFer. we're talking about the greatest QB of all time. he's not even the greatest QB of his franchise's history

That doesn't mean he isn't one of top 10 QBs of all time.

You'd take Starr, Starbauch or Bradshaw over Young?

[pathetic]

Originally Posted by Lee3691

That doesn't mean he isn't one of top 10 QBs of all time.

You'd take Starr, Starbauch or Bradshaw over Young?

the debate is "who is the greatest QB ever" I didn't make the poll. if I did, there would be 3 options. Brady, Montana, 1a/1b

[socopithy]

Originally Posted by pathetic

the debate is "who is the greatest QB ever" I didn't make the poll. if I did, there would be 3 options. Brady, Montana, 1a/1b

See? 1a/1b still puts Brady's name first.

Fucking biased

[rickyh24]

Originally Posted by socopithy

See? 1a/1b still puts Brady's name first.



Fucking biased

Alphabetical order bro.

[bartender_man]

Interesting backread, was hoping this thread was going to die and slip away, guess not...

[Rebecca De Mornay]

assuming brady can snag a better ad campaign than skechers shape ups 20 years after his playing days i think he'll have this one locked up in his favor eventually.

[pathetic]

Originally Posted by Rebecca De Mornay

assuming brady can snag a better ad campaign than skechers shape ups 20 years after his playing days i think he'll have this one locked up in his favor eventually.

poor Montana. downgraded to papa johns commercials with a QB that's a tier below him

[Rebecca De Mornay]

i forgot about that papa johns commerical, that was painful.

[socopithy]

Originally Posted by Rebecca De Mornay

assuming brady can snag a better ad campaign than skechers shape ups 20 years after his playing days i think he'll have this one locked up in his favor eventually.

That tight ass of his though. Those shoes work like magic.

[Rebecca De Mornay]

Originally Posted by socopithy

That tight ass of his though. Those shoes work like magic.

are you about finished?

[socopithy]

Originally Posted by Rebecca De Mornay

are you about finished?

Nah, probably gonna follow you around for a few more months.

Are we friends yet?

[hailtopitt]

JFC make this stop