The one show I went to blew me away, but I only went to one show. I did alot of Setlist watching this year and can see how people who attend multiple shows, or even those that don't like SMLAM or Watchtower could get bored/disappointed...there was a fair amount of repetative songs all in all, but I loved N3 at the Gorge, and wouldn't care less what Dave chooses to play. I liked the acoustic aspect of the show, thought it was much more on-point compared to Mansfield last year, so I think it depends.
Would I like to see the 2sets reappear? Hell yes. Would I like it even more with a new CD tour? I think that would be the only way to see him play next year. Trying to convince my wife to spend the money would be rough, plus we'd need to go to a different venue outside of MA like CT or ME even.
tl;dr - I liked the idea. I think it could be all one set with acoustic mixed in without having 2 seperate sets though, but I really liked it. If I went to more than one show, I don't think my answer would change either.
(Christmas and birthdays are bound to happen if any of you would like to make more than one show happen by the way
)