Re: Do any AFTW songs crack your top 5 on any of the Big 3 albums?
Ok, following the example in the OP (listing based on album versions only for a fair comparison)
UTTAD: BOWA, WWYS, Typical, Nancies, Warehouse
Crash: #41, Crash Into Me, DIDO, Billies, Too Much
BTCS: Rapunzel, Crush, Dreaming Tree, Pig, The Stone
From these, I'd say that album to album, Snow Outside easily beats 3 out of 5 on Crash (all but #41 and Crash Into Me), and maybe one or two on UTTAD. I think the Crush>DT> Pig run is unbeatable, but Snow Outside might edge out Rapunzel on BTCS.
Rooftop, Drunken Soldier, and Broken Things have the possibility to crack into the top 5 with Crash and Maybe UTTAD, but BTCS would not change, as of now.
A lot of this is comparing apples to oranges for me, because the songs are all very different. In a few cases it might come down to what style of song I like better. Also, I don't have as powerful of an attachment to Crash that many of you seem to. I stand by my opinion that, from my perspective, AFTW is even with Crash, if not a little better. Again this is album to album, and not necessarily songs to songs.
|